Categories
Coronavirus daily

Daily Coronavirus Testing at Home? Many Experts Are Skeptical – The New York Times

The buzzy idea is impractical, critics said. And there isn’t yet real-world data to show it will work.

Credit…Dibyangshu Sarkar/Agence France-Presse — Getty Images

Katherine J. Wu

Over the past few weeks, a Harvard scientist has made headlines for a bold idea to curb the spread of the coronavirus: rolling out so-called antigen tests, a decades-old underdog in testing technology, to tens of millions of Americans for near-daily, at-home use.

These tests aren’t very good at picking up low-level infections. But they’re cheap, convenient and fast, returning results in minutes. Real-time information, argued Dr. Michael Mina, would be a lot better than the long delays clogging the testing pipeline.

The fast-and-frequent approach to testing has captured the attention of scientists and journalists around the world, as well as top officials at the Department of Health and Human Services.

Deployed often enough and widely enough, speedy tests could “really squash the virus,” Dr. Mina said. “I think it’s crazy not to get behind this.”

But more than a dozen experts said that near-ubiquitous antigen testing, while intriguing in theory, might not fly in practice — and is unlikely to be a pandemic panacea. In addition to posing herculean logistical hurdles, they said, the plan hinges on broad buy-in and compliance from a country full of people who have grown increasingly disillusioned with testing for the virus. And that’s assuming that rapid tests can achieve their intended purpose at all.

“We are open to thinking outside the box and coming up with new ways to handle this pandemic,” said Esther Babady, director of the clinical microbiology service at Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center in New York. But antigen tests that could work at home have yet to enter the market, she said.

And no one has yet done a rigorous study to show that fast-and-frequent trumps sensitive-but-slow in the real world, she said: “The data for that is what’s missing.”

Although fast-and-frequent testing could work, what’s been put forth so far about the approach has been “largely aspirational, and we need to check it against reality,” said Dr. Alexander McAdam, director of the infectious diseases diagnostic laboratory at Boston Children’s Hospital, who recently co-authored an article on pandemic testing strategies in the Journal of Clinical Microbiology.

Most of the coronavirus tests run so far rely on a laboratory technique called PCR, long considered the gold standard of infectious disease diagnostics because it can pick up even very small amounts of genetic material from germs like the coronavirus.

But sputtering supply chains have compromised efforts to collect, ship and process samples for PCR, driving delays in turnaround times. The longer the wait, the less useful the result. PCR also isn’t cheap or user-friendly, making it an unlikely candidate for widespread home use.

The at-home arena is where antigen tests could shine, Dr. Mina said. At their simplest, they might function much like a pregnancy test, analyzing bodily fluid and spitting out a result within a few minutes, no health workers or fancy machines necessary.

As Dr. Mina sees it, these tests could be crafted from materials as cheap as cardboard and be shipped like rations to communities around the country. They’d act as bouncers at the entrances to schools or workplaces, and allow Americans to check themselves at home for the coronavirus several times a week, perhaps even daily.

But achieving that reality would require an antigen test that is not yet approved for widespread use, and the infrastructure to manufacture it en masse. Only four antigen tests so far have received emergency approval from the Food and Drug Administration, and are intended to be used by health care workers on people who recently showed symptoms. All of them also rely on swabs to collect test samples, and three require somewhat bulky and expensive machines to read out results.

“We just don’t have tests ready to occupy this space right now,” Dr. McAdam said.

Several companies have other rapid tests in development. But there’s no guarantee newcomers will meet F.D.A. standards. And the past few months have clearly demonstrated that no test is impervious to shortages.

“There’s no reason to believe that the supply chain issues we’ve encountered with all other coronavirus testing will not still be an issue here, too,” said April Abbott, microbiology director at Deaconess Health System in Indiana. “We can’t build new product lines overnight.”

Image

Credit…Chandan Khanna/Agence France-Presse — Getty Images

Experts also noted that antigen tests aren’t great at sussing out small amounts of the coronavirus, which means they’re far more likely to miss a case that a technique like PCR would catch. Some antigen tests catch only half the infections they look for. And while some new products perform better in the lab, advertised accuracy rates will almost certainly drop when used at home, said Linoj Samuel, a medical microbiologist at Henry Ford Health System in Michigan.

(Some have argued that PCR may actually be too sensitive in some settings, picking up on scraps of innocuous coronavirus genetic material in patients who are no longer sick; antigen testing could circumvent this.)

Dr. Mina argues that dips in quality could be overcome with quantity: Near-daily tests would be able to identify infections on the cusp of faster than the backlogged PCR pipeline could, helping people self-isolate in the nick of time. From a public health perspective, what matters most is finding people at the peak of infection — something that even antigen tests should be able to do with high levels of accuracy, he said.

But researchers don’t yet know how much virus someone has to have in their body to be contagious — the amount almost certainly varies from person to person. And there will inevitably be exceptions to the “more virus, more transmission” trend.

“We just don’t have any proof that a negative test result means you’re not infectious,” said Susan Butler-Wu, a clinical microbiologist at the University of Southern California’s Keck School of Medicine. Some antigen tests miss up to 18 percent of cases shown by PCR to involve high levels of the coronavirus.

The opposite issue, false positives, are rarer with antigen tests, but they do happen. In July, dozens of positive antigen tests that had officials in Manchester, Vt., bracing for an outbreak turned out to be errors. And in August, Gov. Mike DeWine of Ohio tested positive for the coronavirus by an antigen test, only to test negative thrice in a row by PCR.

In regions where the virus has infected only a few people, the number of false positives could end up dwarfing the number of true positives.

Dr. McAdam said that widely deploying a test with imperfect specificity to a region where the virus is scarce “is a bad idea, and I’ll die on that hill.”

High rates of inaccurate results, coupled with continued confusion about the deluge of new coronaviruses tests, could fuel public skepticism of science at a particularly precarious time, said Amanda Harrington, director of the clinical microbiology laboratory at Loyola University Medical Center in Illinois.

In the past six months alone, coronavirus tests have been alternately billed as game-changers and national embarrassments, seeding a sense of perpetual whiplash among testing experts.

“My own family is telling me they’re not sure what to believe,” Dr. Harrington said. “You’re eroding confidence to the point where people don’t trust it.”

And a nation of people wary of tests will probably be less likely to take them regularly, even if they’re available at home.

Uma Karmarkar, a human behavior expert at the University of California, San Diego, said it’s possible that compliance would be low for the fast-and-frequent approach. She pointed to the example of daily medications, like birth control pills, as well as spotty use of masks.

“Even when there’s a vested interest, there’s slippage,” she said. With near-daily testing, even cheap products could add up to big bills, further disincentivizing use. (Dr. Mina said the federal government should foot the bill to avoid that issue.)

A subset of people might still adopt the fast-and-frequent approach with enthusiasm, Dr. Karmarkar said. But that could be a skewed sector of the population, such as those who are already more inclined to trust the medical system, and could exacerbate the pandemic’s health inequities.

Until more data is gathered to support the fast-and-frequent approach, Dr. Samuel proposed a tentative middle ground. Schools, universities and workplaces may be good candidates for regular antigen testing, for example, whereas hospitals and other medical care settings would still prioritize PCR.

“The whole idea is to use the right test for the right patient at the right time,” Dr. Babady said.

Dr. Mina agreed, noting that PCR remains crucial for diagnosing sick patients — a situation that calls for the most sensitive test, so the right treatments can be administered.

Still, he remains optimistic that the fast-and-frequent strategy could make a major dent in the nation’s coronavirus catastrophe. That should be incentive enough, he said: “I truly believe people will want to use these tests.”

Read More

Categories
daily gaming

Daily Deals: Dell’s Black Friday in July Sale is Ending Today, Massive Savings on Alienware Gaming Laptops and Gaming PCs – IGN

Today is July 31 and Dell’s Black Friday in July Sale is ending soon. Save on the lowest prices we’ve ever seen on Alienware Aurora gaming PCs, Alienware Area 51m desktop replacement laptops, and Alienware m15 and m17 gaming laptops, and more.

Deals for July 31

Alienware Area-51m R1 17

Use code: 50OFF699

Alienware Area-51m R1 17″ 144Hz Intel Core i7-9700K RTX 2070 Gaming Laptop with 16GB RAM, 256GB SSD, 1TB HDD, and Tobii Eye Tracking

Here is your chance to get the best Alienware laptop for an incredibly awesome price. The Alienware Area-51m is a true desktop replacement laptop. It’s the first notebook with a socketed desktop CPU and a swappable GPU. Talk about a future-proof laptop.

Use promo code “50OFF699”

Alienware m15 R2 15

Alienware m15 R2 15″ 240Hz Intel Core i7-9750H RTX 2070 Laptop with 16GB RAM, 512GB SSD, Tobii Eye Tracking

This is a second generation Alienware m15 laptop that weighs in at 4.75 pounds. It has two impressive upgrades: an excellent 15″ 1080p display with 240Hz refresh rate and 100% sRGB color space, and RTX 2070 graphics that is almost as good as a GTX 1080.

Dell G7 15

Dell G7 15″ Intel Core i7-9750H RTX 2060 Gaming Laptop with 16GB RAM, 128GB SSD, 1TB HDD

The G7 is Dell’s highest end laptop outside of Alienware. The RTX 2060 is more powerful than the previous generation’s GTX 1070 and it’s paired with a Core i7 processor and lots of RAM and storage.

Dell G7 15

RTX 2080 Equipped for $1699

Dell G7 15″ 4K OLED Intel Core i7-9750H RTX 2080 Gaming Laptop with 16GB RAM, 1TB SSD

This is the absolute lowest price I’ve seen for an RTX 2080 equipped laptop, ever. It even comes equipped with a 4K OLED display and Core i7 CPU.

Alienware m17 17

New Price Drop

Alienware m17 17″ Intel Core i7-9750H RTX 2060 Gaming Laptop with 16GB RAM, 256GB SSD

This is Alienware’s lightest 17″ laptop ever weighing in at under 6 pounds. The RTX 2060 video card is superior to the previous generation’s GTX 1070.

2src2src Alienware Aurora R11 Intel Core i7-1src7srcsrcF RTX 2src8src SUPER PC with 16GB RAM, 512GB SSD

Use code: 50OFF699

2020 Alienware Aurora R11 Intel Core i7-10700F RTX 2080 SUPER PC with 16GB RAM, 512GB SSD

Save $300 off Dell’s newest Alienware gaming computer. Upgrades include Intel’s new Comet Lake-S processor, HyperX Fury RAM, and a massive 1000W power supply.

Use promo code “50OFF699”

HP Pavillion 16

HP Pavillion 16″ Intel Core i5-10300H GTX 1660 Ti Gaming Laptop with 8GB RAM, 512GB SSD

Nintendo Switch Pro Wireless Controller

Nintendo Switch Pro Wireless Controller

Preorder the LEGO Super Mario Starter Kit Bundle

Out This Saturday

Preorder the LEGO Super Mario Starter Kit Bundle

WD Easystore 5TB USB 3.src Portable Hard Drive

Lowest Price Ever

WD Easystore 5TB USB 3.0 Portable Hard Drive

GTRacing PRO GTsrc99 Gaming Chair

IGN’s Best Budget Gaming Chair of 2020

GTRacing PRO GT099 Gaming Chair

Up to 4src% Off Anker Wireless Accessories

Today Only

Up to 40% Off Anker Wireless Accessories

WD My Passport 512GB External USB 3.1 Gen 2 Portable Solid State Drive (SSD)

WD My Passport 512GB External USB 3.1 Gen 2 Portable Solid State Drive (SSD)

Nintendo Joy-Con (L/R) - Neon Pink / Neon Green

Nintendo Joy-Con (L/R) – Neon Pink / Neon Green

Fallout 76: Wastelanders for PS4 or Xbox One

Fallout 76: Wastelanders for PS4 or Xbox One

More Video Game Deals

Code Vein for PS4 or Xbox

Code Vein for PS4 or Xbox

Ni no Kuni: Wrath of the White Witch Remastered Edition for PS4

Ni no Kuni: Wrath of the White Witch Remastered Edition for PS4

Dragon Quest Builders 2 for PS4

Dragon Quest Builders 2 for PS4

1 Year of PS Plus Membership

Use code: IGNPSN

1 Year of PS Plus Membership

This is a new price drop that brings the price of 1 year of PlayStation Plus down to $34.99. That’s a huge 42% discount compared to the $59.99 price that most people end up paying. PS Plus will very likely carry over to the PS5 console

Read More

Categories
Coronavirus daily

US daily coronavirus deaths surpass 1,000 for first time since June – The Guardian

Daily deaths due to Covid-19 on Tuesday surpassed 1,000 for the first time in the US since the start of June, as Donald Trump admitted the crisis would get worse before it got better.
The seven-day …
Read More