Police Tucson

Tucson Police in Turmoil After Death of Latino Man in Custody – The New York Times

U.S.|Tucson Police in Turmoil After Death of Latino Man in Custody

The police chief of Tucson, Ariz., offered to step down after the release of a video depicting the death of a handcuffed man. Three officers involved have already resigned.




Tucson Police Chief Offers Resignation After Latino Man Dies in Custody

The police chief of Tucson, Ariz., offered to resign after releasing body camera video from two months ago in which a 27-year-old Latino man, Carlos Ingram Lopez, died after being restrained face down for 12 minutes by police officers.

On Thursday, June 18, 2020, before the administrative investigation was completed in its entirety, the three primary officers in the case submitted their resignations to the department. All employees have the right to resign at any time. However, the files for these officers reflect that the department would have terminated them had they not resigned. Public notification should have happened, and we have put steps in place to assure that going forward, any in-custody death is immediately brought to the public’s attention. There have also been questions asked about why it took so long for those of us at an executive level within the department to become aware of the very troubling actions of the officers as seen in the Body One camera footage. Although we were briefed the day following the incident, we did not view the footage at that time. And frankly, that’s something we should have done. To demonstrate my willingness to take accountability for these mistakes, I am offering my resignation to the mayor, city council and city manager, which they can accept or handle as they deem appropriate. Carlos Adrian not only lost his life, but his family lost a son, a grandson — and his daughter lost a father. As mayor and as a mother, I am deeply troubled and outraged by what happened. I am outraged that Carlos Adrian lost his life.

Video player loading

The police chief of Tucson, Ariz., offered to resign after releasing body camera video from two months ago in which a 27-year-old Latino man, Carlos Ingram Lopez, died after being restrained face down for 12 minutes by police officers.CreditCredit…Josh Galemore/Arizona Daily Star, via Associated Press

The police chief of Tucson, Ariz., abruptly offered to resign on Wednesday while releasing a video in which a 27-year-old Latino man, Carlos Ingram Lopez, died in police custody two months ago.

The video, taken by police officers’ body cameras and not made public until Wednesday, depicts a gruesome episode on April 21. Before his death, Mr. Lopez is seen handcuffed while pleading repeatedly in English and Spanish for water and for his nana, or grandmother.

Chief Chris Magnus said officers did not use a chokehold on Mr. Lopez. But he said they violated training guidelines by restraining the victim in a prone position, face down, for about 12 minutes before Mr. Lopez went into cardiac arrest and died at the scene. While he was restrained, Mr. Lopez told the officers he could not breathe.

The autopsy report said the cause of death was a combination of physical restraint and cardiac arrest involving cocaine intoxication. Three officers resigned from the department last Thursday, Chief Magnus said.

The disclosure of Mr. Lopez’s death comes at a time when many Latinos around the United States are calling for changes in how police treat their communities, echoing similar calls by African-Americans. Last week in California, outrage emerged over the killing of Andres Guardado, an 18-year-old Latino student and security guard, by a Los Angeles County sheriff’s deputy. The episode in Tucson occurred about a month before George Floyd, a black man, was killed by police officers in Minneapolis, igniting protests throughout the country.


Credit…Tucson Police Department

Mayor Regina Romero of Tucson appeared shaken while discussing Mr. Lopez’s death at a news conference on Wednesday. She spoke in Spanish, offering condolences to Mr. Lopez’s family, while expressing indignation in English over what happened.

“I am deeply troubled and outraged,” said Ms. Romero, who is the first Latina to serve as mayor of the heavily Latino city. “These officers would have been terminated had they not resigned.”

Two of the officers who resigned are white and one is African-American, said Lane Santa Cruz, a member of the City Council who had been briefed on the episode and reviewed the video on Tuesday. The police chief identified them as Samuel Routledge, Ryan Starbuck and Jonathan Jackson.

Chief Magnus’s own offer to resign seemed to catch Ms. Romero, who was standing by his side, by surprise. She said she would examine the details of what happened before taking action.

The department’s handling of the issue is now coming under intense scrutiny. Authorities did not disclose details about Mr. Lopez’s death until Tuesday, when Ms. Romero canceled a City Council meeting after watching the video.

Before the release of the video, Chief Magnus had publicly described the Tucson police force as one of the more progressive departments in the country. It had previously banned chokeholds and required officers to participate in cultural awareness and crisis intervention training.

Chief Magnus said that officers were responding to a call regarding “disorderly conduct” by Mr. Lopez, who was unclothed and seemed to be acting erratically when the officers arrived at the scene. At one point, an officer told Mr. Lopez he would be shocked with a stun gun if he failed to cooperate.

In the news conference, Chief Magnus said he had asked the F.B.I. to review the episode, which has been under internal investigation in the department. He said the officers involved had not met the standards established in training for what he described as a mental health crisis involving “excited delirium.”

For years, many departments have trained officers that people held face down, in what is known as “prone restraint,” are more likely to die suddenly of positional asphyxia because they have difficulty expanding their chest to bring in air.

This is particularly true if they are showing signs of mental distress or intoxication with stimulant drugs, a condition sometimes referred to as excited delirium. Guidelines for such circumstances usually call for officers to move people onto their side or sit them up as soon as possible.

The autopsy report for Mr. Lopez noted that he was restrained in a prone position with a spit hood, a mesh covering that goes over the head. The officers tried administering CPR to revive Mr. Lopez and also injected him with Narcan, a drug used to revive people overdosing on opioids.

Latino leaders in Tucson expressed dismay and anguish after the video was released. Ms. Santa Cruz, the councilwoman, said the episode underscored how “we are disproportionately being killed by the police.”

Ms. Santa Cruz emphasized how desperate Mr. Lopez was while being restrained, calling for his nana. “In our culture, nanas are the matriarchs,” she said. “He was calling out for his lifeline.”

Jennifer Valentino-Devries contributed reporting.

Read More